Are sugar-free energy drinks bad for you?

Not all drinks labeled sugar-free are indeed sugar-free. Most contain sugar and ingredients that are bad for your health. So, if you are wondering if sugar-free energy drinks are bad for you, keep reading. 

Key Points:

• Sugar-free energy drinks are beverages that are designed to provide an energy boost to the body without the use of sugar.
• Most energy drinks in the market exceed the recommended 400 milligrams of caffeine per can.
• Potential health risks of sugar-free energy drinks include increased heart rate and blood pressure, dehydration and insomnia.
• Other healthier alternatives to sugar-free energy drinks are water, green tea, and fresh fruits.
• Drinking sugar-free energy drinks might not be the ideal choice for you if you have certain medical issues or are sensitive to caffeine.

It’s no news that sugar-free energy drinks have become incredibly popular in recent years, with many people relying on them to get through long work days, workouts, or even just to stay awake during a long drive. 

This sudden increase in the consumption of sugar-free energy drinks is a direct result of brands packaging drinks and labeling them sugar-free, so that people looking for ways to reduce their sugar intake can jump on it. 

Sugar-free energy drinks are widely consumed by young adolescents and students. However, there are concerns about the potential health risks associated with consuming these drinks regularly. 

In this article, we will explore the truth about sugar-free energy drinks and answer the question, are sugar-free energy drinks bad for you even though they are sugar-free?

What Are Sugar-Free Energy Drinks?

Sugar-free energy drinks are beverages that are designed to provide an energy boost to the body without the use of sugar. 

These drinks typically contain a variety of ingredients that are intended to boost energy levels, including caffeine, taurine, and B vitamins. It also incorporates stimulants like ginseng or tea extracts. 

They are often marketed to athletes, students, and anyone who needs a quick pick-me-up. Energy drinks can help people perform better in sports, or stay awake for tasks like work, school, or entertainment.

It is medically recommended to not exceed 400 milligrams of caffeine daily. Most energy drinks in the market usually exceed this amount which points out that they are bad for you. 

Energy drinks are sometimes consumed by athletes before a workout in the hope of improving their performance. Dieters may also choose sugar-free energy drinks in favour of high-calorie foods or drinks to help control their hunger or speed up their metabolism. 

The high caffeine level in energy drinks, together with other substances like guarana (another source of caffeine), and vitamins, contributes to the enticing qualities that make people go for them.

Sugar-free energy drinks come in different forms and flavours, the carbonated ones are packaged as Can drinks while the non-carbonated ones come as concentrated shots that you can gulp at once. 

Common ingredients in sugar-free energy drinks

Some of the most common ingredients that you will find in these beverages include:

Caffeine:

Caffeine is a stimulant that is found in many different types of beverages, including coffee, tea, and soda.

It is also a common ingredient in sugar-free energy drinks. Caffeine is known to improve alertness, concentration, and focus, which is why it is often used by people who need to stay awake or need to be productive.

Taurine:

Taurine is an amino acid that is found in many different types of foods. It is also a common ingredient in sugar-free energy drinks. Taurine is believed to help improve athletic performance, reduce muscle damage, and improve heart health.

Ginseng: 

Ginseng is a herb that is incorporated in most energy drinks because it helps to boost energy, brain function and mental health activities. 

B Vitamins:

B vitamins are a group of vitamins that are essential for overall health and well-being. They are found in many different types of foods, including meat, fish, and dairy products. 

B vitamins are often added to sugar-free energy drinks because they are believed to help improve energy levels and reduce fatigue.

The PROS and CONS of sugar- free energy drinks

The advantages of energy drinks: 

• Increased energy brought on by the caffeine and sugar levels may enhance focus or mental acuity.
• They are simple and convenient
• They are an alternative of choice for individuals who dislike the flavour of coffee 

The disadvantages of energy drinks :

• Energy drinks can worsen coffee addiction and result in caffeine toxicity
• They can trigger cardiovascular problems as a result of an elevated heart rate.
• The caffeine concentration could cause sensations of anxiety, irritability, and nervousness.
• Poor sleep from excess caffeine consumption in energy drinks results in sleep disorders, insulin resistance and obesity. 

READ ALSO:

Ways to improve your sleep hygiene

How much water should you drink a day?

Potential health risks of sugar-free energy drinks 

While sugar-free energy drinks may be effective at boosting energy levels, there are concerns about their potential health risks. Here are some of the most common health risks associated with these beverages:

Increased heart rate and blood pressure

Sugar-free energy drinks are known to increase heart rate and blood pressure. This is because they contain caffeine, which is a stimulant that can cause the heart to beat faster and the blood vessels to constrict. 

For people who already have high blood pressure, consuming sugar-free energy drinks regularly can be particularly dangerous as they may harm a person’s emotions and mental health due to the high caffeine content. 

The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) warns that taking sugar-free energy drinks may make you agitated, restless, and anxious too. 

Insomnia and sleep disturbances

Sugar-free energy drinks are also known to cause insomnia and sleep disturbances. This is because they contain caffeine, which can interfere with the body’s natural sleep-wake cycle. 

People who consume sugar-free energy drinks regularly may find it difficult to fall asleep at night or may wake up frequently during the night.

The National Sleep Foundation encourages enough sleep as the best way to increase energy. You will sleep better and wake up feeling rejuvenated if you have a regular sleep pattern, have a soothing sleep routine, and sleep in a cool, relaxing setting.

Dehydration

Sugar-free energy drinks can also cause dehydration. This is because caffeine is a diuretic, which means that it can cause the body to lose water. 

People who consume sugar-free energy drinks regularly may find that they need to drink more water throughout the day to stay hydrated.

During physical exercise, caffeine and other components in energy drinks may contribute to dehydration according to a 2015 article. 

Studies on the effects of sugar-free energy drinks on the body

There have been several studies conducted to investigate the effects of sugar-free energy drinks on the body.

One study found that consuming sugar-free energy drinks regularly can increase the risk of developing type 2 diabetes. 

Regular and sugar-free energy drinks may harm your heart in addition to causing gastrointestinal problems, acute and chronic headaches, and different psychological issues brought on by caffeine.

Despite these findings, it is important to note that most studies on the effects of sugar-free energy drinks are still in their early stages. More research is needed to fully understand the long-term effects of these beverages on the body.

Comparing sugar-free energy drinks with regular energy drinks

It is worth noting that sugar-free energy drinks are not the same as regular energy drinks. 

Regular energy drinks typically contain large amounts of sugar, which can lead to weight gain, tooth decay, and other health problems. 

Sugar-free energy drinks, on the other hand, are designed to provide an energy boost without the use of sugar.

While sugar-free energy drinks may be a better choice than regular energy drinks, they still come with potential health risks. It is important to consume these beverages in moderation and to be aware of their potential side effects.

Alternatives to sugar-free energy drinks

If you are looking for alternatives to sugar-free energy drinks, there are several options available. Here are some of the best alternatives to consider:

Water

Water is the best choice for staying hydrated throughout the day. Drinking plenty of water can help improve energy levels, reduce fatigue, and improve overall health and well-being.

Green tea

Green tea is a great alternative to sugar-free energy drinks because it contains minimal caffeine and other beneficial compounds that can help improve energy levels and reduce fatigue. 

It is also a good source of antioxidants and other nutrients that are essential for overall health and well-being.

Fresh fruit

Fresh fruit is a great source of natural energy. Eating a piece of fruit when you need a quick energy boost is a great way to stay energized without consuming sugar or caffeine. Fruits that are known to enhance energy include: Pawpaw, guava, African mango, baobab fruit and tamarind.

Tips for reducing your intake of sugar-free energy drinks

If you are looking to reduce your intake of sugar-free energy drinks, here are some tips to consider:

Limit your consumption

Limiting your consumption of sugar-free energy drinks is the best way to reduce your risk of experiencing any negative side effects. Try to limit yourself to one or two drinks per week, and only consume them when you need an energy boost.

Read the labels

Before you consume any sugar-free energy drinks, make sure to read the labels carefully. Look for drinks that contain natural ingredients and avoid anything that contains artificial sweeteners or other additives.

Choose healthier alternatives

As mentioned earlier, there are plenty of healthier alternatives to sugar-free energy drinks. Choose water, green tea, or fresh fruit when you need an energy boost.

Conclusion

Sugar-free energy drinks can be a useful tool for boosting energy levels and improving productivity. 

However, they also come with potential health risks that should not be ignored. 

The high caffeine level in energy drinks is linked to several of its possible adverse effects. Because of this, limiting yourself to one can of an energy drink per day will help guarantee that your caffeine intake stays within safe ranges.

Drinking sugar-free energy drinks might not be the ideal choice for you if you have certain medical issues or are simply sensitive to caffeine. Let a certified doctor or nutritionist advise you on how much caffeine is healthy for you to consume daily.

Choosing healthier alternatives and limiting your consumption can help reduce your risk of experiencing any negative effects.

• Medically reviewed by Dr. Oluwafolajimi Senjobi

References 

Mayo clinic (2023). (Nutrition and healthy lifestyle- Caffeine, how much is too much). 

University of Michigan Covid-19 response – Caffeine Question and Answer.  

Jennifer A et al., (2021). Taurine in sports and exercise 

Jonathon L et al., ( 2005). Single doses of Panax ginseng (G115) reduce blood glucose levels and improve cognitive performance during sustained mental activity.

Dr. Ahmed Abdulrahman (2015). Energy Drink Consumption: Beneficial and Adverse Health Effects.

Omar M et al., (2013). Sleep disorders and the development of insulin resistance and obesity

National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health ( 2018). Energy Drinks. 

Sleep Foundation ( 2023). Caffeine and Sleep

Dr. Ahmed A et al.,(2015). Energy Drink Consumption: Beneficial and Adverse Health Effects.  

Jennifer Markowitz ( 2018). Causes of Temple headache.